Showing posts with label Reading assigment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading assigment. Show all posts

Friday, November 23, 2007

Week 15: Human Macroecology and Historical Dynamics/Course Wrap-up

Greetings All,
This week we are reading a chapter from Peter Turchin's book, War and Peace and War: The Rise and Fall of Empires (2006). The chapter, War and Peace and Particles, outlines Turchin's approach to the study of human history. We are not reading this to understand history or how it should be studied, although we will likely discuss this some, but rather to notice any similarities between human macroecology and the perspective on history that Turchin is trying to build and define. Turchin's arguments relate to some of the things we've discussed about laws and emergent phenomena and his approach to the relationship between individual actions and macroscopic patterns provides an excellent frame for some of our past discussions.
The Chapter we are reading is the beginning of part 3 of the book, which has the goal of defining this scientific approach to the study of history that he calls "cliodynamics." The book is written for a general audience and is generally very well written and easy to follow. However, two terms are mentioned briefly in this chapter, metaethnic frontier and asabiya, that are central to Turchin's theory of historical dynamics. I am elaborating on the definition of these terms and including two excerpts from earlier chapters of his book for the sake of clarity and context on how he uses them

Metaethnic frontiers are defined on pages 5 - 6 (of Turchin 2006) and this leads directly to the role of asabiya in historical dynamics.
The concept of metaethnic frontier emphasizes the importance of ethnicity as a marker of boundaries between groups, be they based on language, rituals, or symbols of dress and custom. Ethnicities are usually nested within each other and single empires may dominate multiple ethnicities, which then may or may not come to share a feeling of solidarity for the empire. Turchin further explains his use of the term as follows:
"The broadest groupings of people that unite many nations are usually called civilizations, but I prefer to call such entities metaethnic communities (from the Greek meta, 'beyond,' and ethnos, 'ethnic group' or 'nation'). My definition includes not only the usual civilizations - the Ester, Islamic, and Sinic, - but also such broad cultural groupings as the Celts and Turco-Mongolian steppe nomads. Typically, cultural difference is greatest between people belonging to different metaethnic communities; sometimes this gap is so extreme that people deny the very humanity of those who are on the other side of the metaethnic fault line.
Historical dynamics can be understood as a result of competition and conflict between groups, some of which dominate others. Domination, however, is made possible only because groups are integrated at the micro level by cooperation among their members. Within-group cooperation is the basis of inter-group conflict, including its extreme versions such as war and even genocide.
Different groups have different degrees of cooperation among their members, and therefore different degrees of cohesiveness and solidarity. Following the fourteenth-century Arab thinker Ibn Khaldun, I call this property of groups asabiya. Asabiya refers to the capacity of a social group for concerted collective action. Asabiya is a dynamic quantity; it can increase or decrease with time. Like many theoretical constructs, such as force in Newtonian physics, the capacity for collective action cannot be observed directly, but it can be measured from observable consequences."

[A metaethnic frontier is a frontier or border between different metaethnic communities.]

The concept of asabiya is "the capacity for social action." The propensity for a group to have asabiya is key to understanding the results of conflicts between empires. It is a central topic in this book and Turchin's earlier monograph on the topic of historical dynamics (Historical dynamics: why states rise and fall). Turchin finds the human potential to cooperate as a crucial social capacity, as it leads to a willingness to make huge sacrifices for the good of some broader social unit.
Asabiya as a concept is thoroughly defined on page 91 as follows:
"The concept of collective solidarity, or asabiya in Arabic, was Ibn Khaldun's most important contribution to our understanding of human history. The theory is described in his monumental The Muqaddimah: An Introduction to History. Asabiya of a group is the ability of its members to stick together, to cooperate: it allows a group to protect itself against the enemies, and to impose will on others. A group with high asabiya will generally win when pitched against a group of lesser asabiya. Moreover, 'royal authority and general dynastic power are attained only through a group and asabiya. This is because aggressive and defensive strength is obtained only through... mutual affection and willingness to fight and die for each other.' In other words, a state can be organized only around a core group with high asabiya. By acting in a solidary fashion, the members of the core group impose their collective will on other constituents of the state and thus prevent the state from falling apart.
But it is not enough to identify group solidarity as the main factor responsible for the strength of the state. Why do some groups have it in abundance, whereas others do not?"

So there's some background on Turchin's goals and use of these terms. We of course are focusing more on the nature of his perspective than specific understandings of history but both are certainly open for discussion.

Like last week there is no annotation for this week but please post a couple of questions and/or comments about War and Peace and Particles on this blog.

************************************************************************************
Some course-related details to keep in mind:
The next two class periods are the wrap-up for the content of the course. On Tuesday (11/27/07) we discuss Turchin and use it as a springboard for Thursday (11/29/07) when we define human macroecology, its goals, techniques, future prospects and limitations. On Thursday we will outline a blog entry and wikipedia article on human macroecology.
As a reminder, please also revisit the readings from the very first week. It may be the case that your take on this first assignment has changed a good deal and it will also be useful for discussion.

Next, we have student presentations. These are the last two class periods of the semester (12/04/07 and 12/06/07). These are informal presentations that have to be less than ten minutes each. Each presenter can get a max of 4 slides which must be emailed to us before hand. We'll have the slides ready for the order of the speakers. The order will be determined with a sign-up sheet on Tuesday of this week.

The presentations are of course about the content of your final papers. These are due on the Wednesday of finals week at 12:00 noon (that's 12/12/07 at 12!).

Another item is the final conversation or oral dialog. This is effectively a final exam where we will ask about your impressions of topics during the course as well as test your comprehension of the major themes of the semester and the arguments of the papers. These will be on the Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday of finals week and we'll figure out specific exam times with a sign-up sheet in class.

As always, please let us know if you have any questions.

Cheers,
Oskar

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Week 14: Economics of energy in human systems

Hey everyone,
Please read the following paper for next week:

Hall et al. 2001. The need to reintegrate the natural sciences with economics. Bioscience 51: 663-673.

(recommended) Smil, V. 2000. Energy in the twentieth century: Resources, conversions, costs, uses, and consequences. Annual Review of Energy & Environment 25: 21-51. (at least look at graphs and highlighted sections, for which will need latest version of Adobe reader)



Figures: Electricity use for night-time

lighting at global, national, and
local (Albuquerque) scales
(click on figures for larger view)


Note: No annotations due this week (Thanksgiving week), but please post your blog comments.




**********************************************
Like organisms, human societies run on energy, and their energy use and characteristics scale with their size. At a minimum, societies need enough energy to fuel the bodily metabolisms of its members. As traditional foragers aggregate into larger groups, they require proportionately less land, suggesting that larger societies, like larger animals, metabolize energy more efficiently (Hamilton et al., 2007b). As people aggregate further, forming large urban settlements, their per-capita infrastructure costs continue to fall with population size, while their gross productivity and creative output rise (Bettencourt et al., 2007). As the average energy use of people along this spectrum increases, they tend to invest more energy in fewer offspring (Moses & Brown, 2003). In essence, a metabolic view of societies illuminates modern changes in human life-history tradeoffs at an individual level and, arguably, at a societal level.

This week, we will examine the role of energetic resources in fueling social metabolism and growth and on accounting for the central role of energy in human economies. It’s not required, but read the highlighted portions and graphs of Smil, 2000, if you have time. Smil, presents an eye-opening history of modern fuel use that shows the central role of external energy in fueling modern human society and social transformations & transitions. How might Smil’s account relate to Tainter’s ideas about high and low gain systems, Hollings ideas on adaptive cycles, and a general “systems” perspective on human ecology?

In arguing for integrating nature’s constraints into mainstream economics, Hall et al., 2001, provides a springboard for embedding hierarchical socio-economic systems within broader biophysical systems. Fig 2 presents a good view of this idea. We chose Hall not to launch a polemic against standard economics but rather to stimulate discussion on widening our systems perspective to include nature’s economy, especially the role of energy. From a geographic perspective, how do energy sources “map on” to the distribution of humans on the globe? Is a Diamondesque view helpful, that the geography of energy sources influences patterns of wealth and development? How are these sources distributed, both originally and through redistribution networks, and what are the implications?

Hall et al., 2001, also raise the issue of integrating ecology and economics, which have natural parallels and paradigms. Both ecology and economics come from the Greek “oikos,” meaning “house.” They share similar ideas of “capital” as wealth, monetary wealth in economics and the “embodied capital” of the body and its abilities in human evolutionary ecology. Ecology’s food webs are clearly akin to human economies of buyers, sellers, firms, and so on. And optimization plays key roles in life history theory (i.e. fitness maximization) and economic theory (i.e. utility maximization). A well-known ecology textbook encapsulates the ideas that natural systems run on energy and use it efficiently in its title, The Economy of Nature. As Brown et al. discuss in “The fractal nature of nature,” a scaling perspective of human ecology makes the same argument.

Given how wide-ranging the idea of valuing natural resources generally*, I’d rather focus on energy and build explicitly on our conceptual foundations in systems theory, scaling, and life history. Economists Herman Daly, Partha Dasgupta, Robert Constanza, and Kenneth Arrow, among others, have written extensively on the importance of proper valuation of natural resources and the related concept of sustainability. From ecology, H.T. Odum pioneered an energetic perspective, and C.S. Holling, Carl Folke, Lance Gunderson, and Stephen Carpenter have further developed “systems ecology” with humans and energy in mind.

We’re considering the value of a systems perspective of human ecology. How does it differ from traditional views? This macroscopic view uses scaling and hierarchy theory to backlight the often invisible networks that move and connect genes, energy, and information. It uses complexity theory to understand how nodes in these networks, such as actors on an agricultural landscape, use simple rules to generate emergent, systemic behavior. And it effectively uses economic theory to see how costs, benefits, and trade-offs connect individual decisions to global outcomes.

Looking forward to our discussion,

Bill


* See Daily et al. 2000. The value of nature and the nature of value. Science 289: 395-396 for a good general discussion of valuing ecosystem services written by a “who’s who” of ecologists and economists.

** If you're curious, here's a link to the New Mexico state profile from the U.S. Energy Information Administration, which has a wealth of information: http://tonto.eia.doe.gov/state/state_energy_profiles.cfm?sid=NM


Friday, November 9, 2007

Week 13: Scaling part 2

The following papers are required readings for next week. A few optional papers are in the ereserves folder as well.

*Hamilton M. et al. 2007. The complex structure of hunter-gatherer social networks. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B.

* Bettencourt, L. M. A., J. Lobo, D. Helbing, C. Kuhnert, and G. B. West. 2007. Growth, innovation, scaling, and the pace of life in cities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104:7301.

*Moses, M. E., and J. H. Brown. 2003. Allometry of human fertility and energy use. Ecology Letters 6:295-300.

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Week 12: Scaling (part 1)

Required Readings
*Brown, J. H. 2002. The fractal nature of nature: power laws, ecological complexity and biodiversity. Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences 357:619-626.
*Gibson, C. C., E. Ostrom, and T. K. Ahn. 2000. The concept of scale and the human dimensions of global change: a survey. Ecological Economics 32:217-239.
*pages 1771-1777 of Brown, J. H., J. F. Gillooly, A. P. Allen, V. M. Savage, and G. B. West. 2004. Toward a Metabolic Theory of Ecology. Ecology 85:1771-1789.

Optional
Schneider, D. C. 2001. The Rise of the Concept of Scale in Ecology. BioScience 51:545 – 553.

Friday, October 26, 2007

Week 11: Energetics, culture, and society



These papers discuss the importance of energy in governing the dynamics and self-organization of complex systems. Howard .P. Odum, Leslie A. White, Boltzmann , Schrodinger (Schrödinger 1992), and Lottka (Lotka 1922) were some of the pioneers in researching the importance of energy in biological and human systems. Such scientists have sought to develop general principles of complex systems and evolution, often framed within the context of thermodynamics. Odum has had a profound influence in several scientific fields, including ecological economics, ecosystem ecology, general systems theory, ecological modeling, environmental engineering, and education. Tim F.H. Allen has been an important thinker in the development of ecological theory (e.g., Allen 1992). However, many of the ideas in these papers have yet to be rigorously developed and tested. In your writings for this week try to:

(1) carefully evaluate their reasoning and mechanistic explanations

(2) describe connections between these authors' ideas and other papers in the course

(3) and think of ways that these ideas could be built into more testable hypotheses.

Jordan



Please read the following for the coming week:

* White, L.A. 1943. Energy and the evolution of culture. American Anthropologist 45: 335-356.
* Odum, H.T. 1988. Self organization, transformity, and information. Science 242: 1132-1139.
* Tainter, J.A. et al. 2003. Resource transitions and energy gain: Contexts of organization. Conservation Ecology 7:  4 - 17.
********************************************************************************************
Additional references

Allen, T. F. H. 1992. Toward a Unified Ecology. Columbia Univ Pr.

Lotka, A. J. 1922. Contribution to the Energetics of Evolution. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 8:147-151.

Schrödinger, E. 1992. What is life? Cambridge Univ. Press.


Friday, October 19, 2007

Week 10: Complex human ecological systems & their dynamics


Read the following, ideally in this order:

* (Recommended) Costanza et al. 1995. Modeling complex ecological economic systems. Bioscience 43: 545-549 (stop at “Fractals and chaos”)

*Holling, C.S. 2001. Understanding the Complexity of Economic, Ecological, and Social Systems. Ecosystems 4: 390-405.

*Lansing & Kremer. 1993. Emergent properties of Balinese water temple networks.

* Arquitt et al. 2005. A systems dynamics analysis of boom & bust in the shrimp aquaculture industry


Kruse, J. et al 2004, Liu et al. 2007, and Chapin. 2006. are optional but have some good points, definitions, and figures.

NOTE: You DO NOT need to summarize or comment on Costanza. ALSO, since Kruse was up as "required" for a day and Arquitt was not, you can summarize either for credit. Arquitt will be more useful to you, though.

FINALLY, you can take till Friday at 10am to e-mail us your proposals, and feel free to write compact annotations/comments this week. Just show us your understanding of the ideas and how they interact and any questions or ideas they raise.

************************************************************************

Unit II_ A Systems Perspective in Human Ecology: Complexity, Dynamics, Scaling, and Social Metabolism

This week we start our unit on a systems perspective on human ecology, pioneered by ecologists H.T. Odum and C.S. Holling, among others. A concept diagram for how the unit topics relate to those from this week is:

Systems thinking --> systems theory/science --> complex systems --> complex human ecological systems --> understanding how complex human eco-systems change over time (dynamics)

… modelers of systems usually look for boundaries that minimize the interaction between the system under
study and the rest of the universe in order to make their job easier. The interactions between ecological and economic systems are many and strong. So, splitting the world into separate economic and ecological systems is a poor choice of boundary.
Costanza et al. 1993

Holling, 2001, advocates a particular view of human eco-systems and their dynamics. How does the idea of adaptive cycles differentiate a hierarchy from Holling’s notion of a panarchy? What are examples in human ecological systems? What do you think of this framework for understanding and modeling complex human eco-systems?

…a spontaneous process of self-organization occurred when we allowed water temples to react to changing environmental conditions over time in a simulation model. Lansing & Kremer, 1993

Steve Lansing, an anthropologist at U. Arizona, has worked extensively in Bali on the intricate ecological relationships between people and landscape, focusing on traditional agricultural and water-management systems. Lansing & Kremer, 1993, is a classic case study of a human-environment complex adaptive system. What are some “emergent properties” of the Balinese water temple networks? What’s an appropriate null hypotheses for their question? What role do feedbacks play in their understanding of the water-temple network?

Arquitt et al, 2005, showcases the “systems dynamics” approach. They are interested in modeling the boom and bust pattern of the Thai shrimp fishing industry as a system. In so doing, they aim to identify appropriate points and mechanisms for intervention to promote greater sustainability. Think about pros and cons of this approach. Think also about the similarities and differences between Arqitt’s approach and that of Lansing & Kremer.

Note the central role of adaptation in all three papers and approaches. Adaptation plays a central role in behavioral ecology, the study of behavioral interactions between organisms and their environment. In systems ecology, the system is the equivalent of an organism, and its “behavior” includes how it and its “outputs” change over time.

As we go move through this unit, think about how the idea of a system, as defined in the glossary, relates to a broad definition of metabolism—the acquisition, transformation, and allocation of energy, matter, or information. How can a metabolic perspective inform and enhance a systems perspective? Can we fruitfully extend this idea from organismal biology to human ecology?

Happy musings,

Bill


Glossary:

chaotic – behavior of a system over time whose trajectory is very dependent on initial conditions and that exhibits nonlinearity. Lansing & Kremer, p. 110, give a nice if abstract verbal description of the difference between chaotic and complex behavior of a system.

complex system – a energetically “open” system of parts, often organized hierarchically, that interact via complex feedback loops to produce nonlinear behavior and often emergent patterns. Examples include ecosystems, economies, and the human immune system.

complex adaptive system – a complex system containing adaptive agents, networked so that the environment of each adaptive agent includes others in the system. (Holland & Miller, 1991)

emergent properties / emergence – properties of a system that are unpredictable from just understanding properties and isolated behaviors of its components. For example, simply studying the behavior of individual ants would not enable you to predict the behavior of a large colony; the complex colonial behavior emerges from the collective, relatively simple behaviors of the individual ants that comprise it.

feedback – in a system, the effect of an output on an input. Positive feedback amplifies the output, while negative feedback dampens it. A classic example is the effect of temperature on a thermostat.

model – (n) a representation of a system; models can be verbal, graphical, or mathematical

nonlinear – behavior, as of a system, that is not a simple sum of the behavior of its elements

resilience – in ecology, the ability of a system to remain unchanged or well-functioning when under some type of pressure

robustness – ability to maintain function or effectiveness under different conditions or limitations. For example, a model is considered robust if you can change assumptions and the model still captures what you intended. Robustness usually refers to a system's function, while resilience refers to the system's structure.

stock and flow diagram – in systems dynamics, a flowchart diagram that highlights relationships between entities that accumulate or deplete over time, called stocks, and their rates of change, called flows

system – a group of “interacting, interdependent parts linked together by exchanges of energy, matter, and information.” Costanza et al. 1993

system dynamics – a) changes over time in a system, b) a field that explores how complex systems change over time

systems thinking – a nonreductionist approach to understanding and studying systems that considers the parts, their connections, and their interactions wholistically. Lansing & Kremer and Arquitt et al. are both examples of a systems approach to human ecology.

threshold – the “tipping point” between one state of a system and another. Landmasses on the sides of a geologic fault, for example, change relative positions when the pressure on them exceeds some threshold.

Friday, October 12, 2007

Week 9: Ecology and Geography of Wealth and Resource Use

Exploring the global ecology, geography, and ecological economics of contemporary humans

“The human economy depends on the planet’s natural capital, which provides all ecological services and natural resources” (Wackernagel et al. 2002). Spatial flows of energy and materials, such as fossil fuel, wood, and food, between humans across the globe provide resilience to the global economy and sustain local economies in depauperate environments. Geographic differences in the natural, social, and economic environments govern this supply and demand network of flows. Some of the exchanges are necessary to sustain comfortable standards of living and the resilience of local economies, whereas other exchanges may maintain ecologically damaging differences in wealth or be unnecessarily wasteful. This week’s readings provide insight into these processes, examining the degree of matching between human demand and environmental resource supply, and some of the ultimate and proximate factors underlying geographic patterns in wealth and resource use.

As suggested by Liu et al. (2003), changes in the number and size of households result from complex interactions between local resource availability, per capita income, population dynamics, demographic changes, and cultural values. Individuals living in smaller households generally use resources and space less efficiently than larger households, thereby increasing their impact on the environment. Some of these impacts and patterns of consumption are investigated by Wackernagel et al. (2002) and Imhoff et al. (2004). Imhoff et al. describe remarkable spatial variation in the consumption by humans of ecosystem productivity. Wackergael et al.’s results suggest that Homo sapiens’ demand on the biosphere may exceed its current capacity.

Drawing from ideas developed by Jared Diamond in Guns, Germs, and Steel, Hibbs and Olsson’s (2004) use models to argue that the distribution of agriculturally supportive environments (namely related to climate and availability of plants and animals suitable for domestication) and the geographic orientation of continents account for a large part of differences in the wealth of nations. Many patterns in human consumption and environmental degradation reflect these differences in wealth. For example, individuals with higher per capita incomes may choose to live in large houses, commute further to work, and consume more energy and resources. Thus furthering our understanding of economic development and the geography of wealth is essential towards developing a theory of modern human macroecology. The Hibbs and Olsson’s paper is only one perspective and introduction to this vast subject.

Together these readings underscore the importance of developing an understanding of human ecology and biogeography that integrates the natural and social sciences from local to global scales. Such a synthetic understanding is essential towards effectively building a sustainable and relatively poverty-free future.

Cheers,
Jordan

Note to class: please post this week's proposal peer review assignment on last weeks proposal blog entry.

Readings

  • Hibbs, D. Jr., and O. Olsson. 2004. Geography, biogeography, and why some countries are rich and others are poor. PNAS 101: 3715-3720.
  • Liu, J., G. C. Daily, P. R. Ehrlich, and G. W. Luck. 2003. Effects of household dynamics on resource consumption and biodiversity. Nature 421:530-533.
  • Bounoua, L., T. Ricketts, C. Loucks, R. Harriss, and W. T. Lawrence. 2004. Global patterns in human consumption of net primary production. Nature 429:870-873.
  • Wackernagel, M., N. B. Schulz, D. Deumling, A. C. Linares, M. Jenkins, V. Kapos, C. Monfreda, J. Loh, N. Myers, and R. Norgaard. 2002. Tracking the ecological overshoot of the human economy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 99:9266-9271.

Friday, October 5, 2007

Week 8: Human influences on biogeographic patterns

Hey all,
This is a complex topic and we could spend a long time on it. BUT - the goal here is to round-out our discussion of humans and biogeography by giving examples of not just how patterns in human variation follow biogeographic trends but also how some of the things humans do alter biogeographic patterns in other species. The easiest example here is with the human role in extinction but we certainly have impacts on the distribution, abundance, and rate of spread of a number of species. For example, where would cows be without us? Also, our investments in domesticates create a number of interesting dynamics from the discharge of fertilizers into the ocean to land disturbance causing the spread of some species over others. etc. etc.

The papers for this week are as follows:
*Evans, K. L., and K. J. Gaston. 2005. RESEARCH PAPER: People, energy and avian species richness. Global Ecology and Biogeography 14:187-196.
*Sutherland, W.J. 2003. Parallel extinction risk and global distribution of languages and species. Nature 423: 276-279.
*Lyons, K. S., F. A. Smith, and J. H. Brown. 2004. Of mice, mastodons, and men: human-mediated extinctions on four continents. Evolutionary Ecology Research 6:339-358.
*Surovell - a first proof of his entry entitled "Inter-regional studies/Big game extinctions" for the upcoming Encyclopedia of Archaeology.

We are going to do the reading assignment a bit differently this week because of Fall Break.
For your annotations you should read the Lyons et al (2004) paper and any one of the other three. Basically, your annotation just needs to make it clear that you read at least two papers (the Lyons paper and one other). If you are really interested in overkill (the debated role of human hunting pressure in the disappearance of large game at the end of the Pleistocene) then your second paper should be the Surovell chapter. If you are interested in language read the Sutherland paper. The Evans and Gaston paper speaks to some incredibly cool relationships but is fairly technical with respect to statistics. As always - please spend some time with all the papers - but you only need to focus on two.

I will put a separate post up this weekend about background information for the papers.
Please let me know in an email if there is anything specific you'd like to have defined/explained.

Best,
Oskar

PS - everyone did a great job on Thursday. I think we had an excellent discussion of the McDade and Sherman and Billing papers. Was this because of the interest in the material or because of the coffee!?

Friday, September 28, 2007

Week 7: Cultural, linguistic, genetic diversity patterns II


For this week, please read the following, ideally in the order listed:

[suggested] Reread Pagel & Mace, 2004, starting at “Cultures and gene flow,” p. 276

Cavalli-Sforza et al., 1988. Reconstruction of human evolution: Bringing together genetic, archaeological, and linguistic data.

Sherman & Billing. 1999. Darwinian gastronomy: Why we use spices.

McDade et al., 2007. Ethnobotanical knowledge and child health in Bolivia.

[Optional] Ackland et al. 2007. Cultural hitchhiking on the wave of advance of beneficial technologies.

**********************************************************************

This week we will a) look explicitly at the relationships between genetic diversity and linguistic diversity and their relation to human evolution, b) continue exploring cultural diversity gradients, focusing on a gradient in the use of spices, derived from plants, and c) explore how maternal knowledge about plants effects child health. I think these connections are pretty amazing, and I hope you enjoy the papers. This last article, in a sense, brings us full circle back to some basic life-history considerations.

Keith Hunley, an assistant prof of Anthropology at UNM, will lecture on Tuesday and asked that we read Cavalli-Sforza as background for his talk. Cavalli-Sforza pioneered the use of gene frequency data and allied methods to study the movements and evolution of people and their biological and linguistic traits. This paper has some jargon and a genetics and evolution bent, but focus on the overall findings and implications. The last portion explicitly relates the overall findings to human ecology. Think about the forces that selected for general language ability and, at the same time, the partitioning of this human universal into about 6900 varieties.

There’s debate about the correspondence between patterns of linguistic and human genetic diversity patterns. Some authors have reached different conclusions from Cavalli-Sforza. Think about likely mechanisms underlying linguistic & genetic evolution. Why would or wouldn’t you expect agreement between them? What ecological factors likely affect them? And how might you test for relationships?

Sherman & Billing take a macroecological approach to analyzing patterns in spice use across the globe. It’s an innovative look at cultural diversity gradients and at a hypothesis for an underlying mechanism. What other mechanisms could underlie this pattern? Paul Sherman wrote a well-cited paper called “The Levels of Analysis,” which the authors cite in the article we read and which argues that researchers should consider both the “proximate” and “ultimate” explanations for traits. A proximate explanation focuses on physiological and genetic mechanisms, while an ultimate explanation focuses on underlying evolutionary reasons. For example, a proximate explanation for the spiciness of chiles is the concentration of the tongue-searing biochemical capsaicum and the prescence of genes coding for it. An ultimate explanation is the adaptive benefit to chiles of deterring mammals from eating their fruits, because mammals are more likely to chew the seeds and drop them too close to the parent plant or deep underground. Birds are much better dispersers of chile seeds and, not surprisingly, don’t taste capsaicum. What are possible proximate reasons people in warm climates use more spices, and are they compatible with the authors’ hypothesis for ultimate reasons?

“… the intergenerational transmission of knowledge regarding the use of available plant resources has historically been an essential function of culture.” McDade et al., 2007

McDade et al., 2007, looks at the relationship between parent’s ethnobotanical knowledge, or knowledge of local plant resources, and the health of their children among the Tsimane, a foraging society in Bolivia. It links together several themes we’ve discussed, including diversity gradients, health and local ecology, height differences, human learning period, intergenerational knowledge transfer, and longevity. Try drawing a diagram linking these ideas. How would you expect spices with anti-inflammatory properties, such as turmeric, to affect longevity, and why? How might gradients in plant and spice diversity affect linguistic patterns? How could you test for such relationships?

Lastly, I want to encourage the quieter voices in the class to let us hear your thoughts and insights a bit more. Likewise, I want to encourage bolder students to leave a bit more “air time” for others to enter the discussion, even if that means the occasionally silence. One of the strengths of a diverse class is the potential for a diversity of perspectives. And just as species diversity includes both “richness” and “evenness,” I want to maximize the diversity of our discussions, with all participating in a significant way. Thanks for your consideration and effort on these points.

See you Tuesday.

Bill


Glossary:

admixture – mixture of two or more genotypes; mixing of genetically different groups

allele – version of a (polymorphic) gene. For example, a population of wild rose that has both red and white flowers has different alleles for flower color.

bootstrap – (also called bootstrapping) a statistical technique for making educated guesses about a population by randomly sampling with replacement from the sample you have, creating distributions of those samples, and assuming the distribution of those samples mirrors the “sampling distribution” of your original population. So if you just have one sample from a population and you don’t think the pop has a normal distribution, you use the distribution of samples of your real sample to infer what the distribution of actual samples from the true population what look like. Regardless of the specifics, it’s a powerful method for inferring characteristics of a population based on a single, usually large sample. Cavalli-Sforza used bootstrapping to test hypothetical human evolutionary “trees” using a large sample of genetic distances for genes shared by human populations. If you want to know more, read “The Bootstrap Conjecture” in http://www.uvm.edu/~dhowell/StatPages/Resampling/Bootstrapping.html.

demographic bottleneck – a sharp reduction in population size, which tends to reduce genetic diversity the same way taking a small handful of M&Ms from a giant bowl is unlikely to capture the variety of colors in the original “population”

electrophoretic – involving electrophoresis, which is the identification of organic compounds via the distance they move through a gel when under an electric charge; small compounds move faster and so further in a given time

gene frequency – relative frequency of a given gene in a population

genetic distance – relative genetic dissimilarity between individuals, populations, or species. A common null hypothesis is that the genetic distance between two samples, such as between two populations of people, indicates the amount of time they’ve been separated. The underlying reason for this null hypothesis is that much of our DNA, including the “genetic marker” portions used for many studies, has no real effect on our genetic fitness or adaptedness yet still accumulates “adaptively neutral” mutations at a low, stable, background rate that can be used as a “molecular clock.” The number of unshared mutations between populations on such a genetic marker represents the “ticks” of this clock: the time the two groups have lived apart, not interbred, and undergone separate evolution. What’s an alternative hypothesis for the genetic distance between two populations?

genetic drift – change in the frequency of one or more genes in a population due to chance, as because some members happen to have more offspring for reasons unrelated to adaptatedness; along with natural selection, genetic drift is one mechanism behind evolution; the frequency of a given gene is more likely to “drift” one way or another in a small population, just as a small number of coin tosses is more likely to give a non-50/50 ratio of heads/tails than a large
number of coin tosses

linkage analysis – an analysis of the amount of linkage between genes. Linkage is the tendency for genes located near each other on a chromosome to be inherited together.

maximum likelihood – statistical method for evaluating phylogenetic trees that favors the “tree” with the highest probability of being correct given your constraints

maximum parsimony – statistical method for evaluating phylogenetic trees that literally favors the “tree” that requires the fewest evolutionary changes to explain the variation in a group of related organisms

phylogenetic tree – evolutionary family tree, as of genes or of languages.

polymorphism – alternate version of a trait or gene

population – the individuals of a species living in the same area at the same time and so having a good chance of interbreeding; Note that biological evolution occurs within populations as the frequency of genes changes among its members.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

Week 6: Cultural, linguistic, & genetic diversity patterns 1



For the coming week, please read the following, ideally in this order:

1. Moore et al. 2002. The distribution of biological & cultural diversity in Africa

2. Collard & Foley. 2002. Latitudinal patterns & environmental determinants of recent human cultural diversity

3. Pagel & Mace. 2004. The cultural wealth of nations.

4. (Optional) Nettle. 1998. Explaining global patterns of language diversity. [Nettle

5. (Optional) Cashdan. 2001. Ethnic diversity and its environmental determinants.

6. (Very Optional) Serre & Paabo. 2004. Evidence for gradients of human genetic diversity

Maps: (top) topography; (2nd) annual precipitation; (3rd) vascular plant species diversity, (bottom) world language diversity


Click on these maps to see them in greater detail.


********************************************************************************************

Humans are part of ecological systems and have various ecological relationships and associated life history patterns. Then again, unlike other large mammals, humans have permanent settlements on every continent and in almost every known terrestrial environment. Humans are relatively genetically homogenous, yet we display astonishing cultural and linguistic variability that follows clear geographic patterns. Is that variability a function of environmental variables, like climate or ecosystem type? Where human cultural patterns mirror biogeographic patterns of other species, are humans responding to the same forces? In the same ways? Why or why not, and how do you test such questions anyway? To start with, how do you fruitfully think about variation in cultural and social patterns—as discrete entities, as clines, or otherwise? Are these differences comparable to other biogeographic differences, and why? More broadly, what is the relationship between culture, language, and environment? Finally, how does human life history, such as lifespan and learning period, factor into such patterns and relationships?

These are some of the questions we’ll ponder and discuss over the coming two weeks. You will struggle with these ideas, occasionally you will triumph, you will laugh, you will cry. I’ll provide Kleenex.

On a more serious note, carefully read the required articles and, if time, the abstracts and figures in the optional articles. Moore et al., 2002, focuses on the relationship between language “richness” (see Glossary below) and species richness in Africa. Collard & Foley, 2002, takes a macroecological look at latitudinal patterns of cultural diversity and possible environmental determinants. Pagel & Mace, 2004, is a good, readily digestible review of current hypotheses on the relationship between culturo-linguistic diversity and environmental variation.

The optional articles provide good reference for the required ones and offer additional hypotheses. Nettle is very active in debates about linguistic diversity, and this paper gives his most widely-known view, which Pagel & Mace summarize and reference. Cashdan has done lots of work with hunter-gatherers and looks carefully at several ecological variables. If you are interested in reading more or following this topic for your project, Nettle and Cashdan are great starting points. Serre & Paabo provides some good recent context on the relationship between human genetic & linguistic patterns, but it’s useful here just for context on how human mating and migration patterns relate to linguistic patterns; we’ll focus explicitly on this topic next week.

If you come across terms in the papers you don't know, consult the Glossary below for reference and understanding. You don't need to memorize these terms, but understanding these concepts will help with the papers.

Ciao,

Bill


p.s. Also consider that languages and cultures, like species, are disappearing at a clip. A recent NYT article (http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/19/science/19language.html?em&ex=1190433600&en=7e3479621ae1b054&ei=5087%0A)

estimated that one of humanity’s approximately 6900 languages is “lost” every two weeks. Indeed, language and cultural documentation and preservation is an active field, and a major thrust is the tight link between biological and culture-linguistic diversity.


Glossary:

allopatry – separation of a population into two or more groups via a physical barrier, such as a mountain chain or a river; allopatric speciation is the formation of two or more species as such physically divided populations genetically and behaviorally diverge

biome – one of the Earth’s main, usually terrestrial, ecosystem types, such as desert, tropical rain forest, and tall-grass prairie

carrying capacity – the maximum population size of a given species that a given environment can support relatively stably over time

correlation – in statistics, the strength and direction of the linear relationship between two variables

diversity, species—in ecology, a measure of the diversity of species in a given area that considers both “richness,” or number of species, and “evenness,” or evenness of the population sizes of those species

endemic—native and often unique to a given area

evapotranspiration—the transfer of water vapor from Earth's surface to the air from evaporation and transpiration (transpiration is the release of water vapor from plant leaves & stems as a byproduct of photosynthesis) ; potential evapotranspiration is the maximum water vapor an ecosystem could release if it got enough rain.; actual evapotranspiration is the amount of water vapor an ecosystem does release given the average precipitation it usually gets.

genetic marker— a known DNA sequence whose presence and variation can be used to infer the degree of relatedness among groups of organisms

horizontal transmission— transmission, as of a word’s meaning or a custom, within a society other than between parent and child (i.e. other than “down the generations”)

PCA (principal components analysis)— a statistical technique for reducing the number of dimensions of interest among a group of variables; generally, it helps you see which attributes of a dataset contribute most to the patterns of interest; it’s a complex idea that you don’t really need to know…I’m just defining it generally because a paper refers to it

phylogenetic tree—a tree-like diagram showing the evolutionary relationships among species or other entities sharing a common ancestor

population —in ecology, the individuals of a given species living together and interbreeding in a given area

productivity—in ecology, the amount of new living (plant) tissue produced, usually over a year’s time[so warm areas with high precipitation produce lots of new plant material per unit time and so have high productivity]; Gross primary productivity is the total CO2 transformed into living tissue, while net primary productivity is this "gross" amount minus the amount used for the plant's metabolism

reproductive isolation—the separation of two or more groups from possible interbreeding; over time, reproductive isolation often promotes the formation of distinct species, or speciation

richness – number or variety, as of species, languages, or cultures. (e.g. The endemic plant species richness of New Mexico is simply the number of plant species native to the state.)

Rapoport’s rule – the tendency for species range size to increase with increasing latitude (i.e. species at high latitudes tend to occupy large ranges and vice versa)

spatial autocorrelation— the degree of spatial, usually geographic, clustering among features of interest; for example, closely related species tend to have ranges that are spatially autocorrelated simply because they descend from a parent species that presumably lived in the general area (i.e. their ranges aren’t clustered simply because the species have similar niches); very generally, it says two points close together are more likely to be similar than two points further apart

species-area relationship – the positive relationship between the size of a habitat and the number of species it can support and that you'll find there [how might this logic be extended to human ecology?]

sympatry – (literally, “same father”) deriving from a single parent species and living in the same area; so sympatric speciation is the formation of two or more species from the same “parent species” without the help of some obvious barrier to interbreeding

vertical transmission—transmission, as of a word’s meaning or a custom, between parent and child (i.e. “down the generations”)

Saturday, September 15, 2007

Readings for week 5: variation in human body form part 2, the role of density dependence

This week we are reading a few papers that establish links between life history theory and body size evolution in general and also serve to better acquaint us with the empirical patterns of body size and growth in living humans. (note: these papers are slightly different from what's on the syllabus! We substituted Crimmins and Finch with Palkovacs)

The assigned papers are as follows:

Walker, R., M. Gurven, K. Hill, A. Migliano, N. Chagnon, R. D. Souza, G. Djurovic, R. Hames, A. M. Hurtado, H. Kaplan, K. Kramer, W. J. Oliver, C. Valeggia and T. Yamauchi
2006 Growth rates and life histories in twenty-two small-scale societies. American Journal of Human Biology 18(3):295-311.

Palkovacs, E. P.
2003 Explaining adaptive shifts in body size on islands: a life history approach. Oikos 103:37 - 44.

Stiner, M. C., N. D. Munro, T. A. Surovell and E. Tchernov, Bar-Yosef, Ofer
1999 Paleolithic Population Growth Pulses Evidenced by Small Animal Exploitation. Science 283:190 - 194.


The Walker et al paper shows empirical patterns in growth and body size among contemporary hunter-gatherer populations. Pay close attention to the general relationships that this paper demonstrates. In parts of the paper there are a lot of statistics that you may or may not be familiar with. As always, do not get bogged down in the technical language. Do your best and maybe google some or all of the terms you aren't familiar with (if there are any). The discussion section of the paper is quite lucid and does a good job of clarifying the implications of the statistics in the paper.

The Palkovacs paper takes a life history approach to explaining the patterned changes in body size that are described by the Island Rule. To the best of my knowledge this is the only life history approach to the problem that has been published. What do you think of the approach taken in this paper? Is it more complicated than it needs to be? Is there anything missing or is there any extraneous detail? Remember the definition of a reaction norm that we mentioned briefly in class on Thursday. A given gene doesn't necessary code for a single static phenotype. Phenotypes can change depending on the conditions of the external environment. This capacity for change is a reaction norm. Some examples include changes in skin color in response to sun exposure or changes in growth rate in response to energy availability.

The paper by Stiner and colleagues is an archaeological analysis of data that might seem removed from what we've been talking about. But when do we see changes in human diet and what types of changes occur? What might cause these changes? What was going on with human body size at this time? Do any of the patterns we see in Stiner et al. relate to what we are learning about body size change in Walker et al. and from Palkovacs?

We have also posted a few optional papers showing that some of the same tradeoffs we've been discussing in the contexts of the Island Rule and among hunter-gatherer growth patterns are present in industrial economies. These papers are really exciting and I hope you can check some of them out, especially now that you're armed with some theoretical tools to put these patterns into a larger context. (For readers outside the class - note that you can access these papers by following the directions and hotlink on the sidebar to the right where it says 'ereserves').

Please let me know or post a comment as soon as you can if there are questions about terms and/or concepts in these papers.

I hope you all have great weekends.
Oskar

Saturday, September 8, 2007

Readings for week 4: variation in human body form

This week we read two papers that show interesting patterns, across space and through time, in the size and shape humans. Here they are:

Morwood M.J., Soejono R.P., Roberts R.G., Sutikna T., Turney C.S.M., Westaway K.E., Rink W.J., Zhao J.x., van den Bergh G.D., Due R.A., Hobbs D.R., Moore M.W., Bird M.I. & Fifield L.K. (2004) Archaeology and age of a new hominin from Flores in eastern Indonesia. Nature, 431, 1087-1091

Ruff, C. 2002. Variation in Human Body Size and Shape. Annual Review of Anthropology 31:211 - 232.


There is some technical language in each paper. For instance, the Ruff paper discusses some of the methodological issues in estimating stature from skeletal measurements. Don't worry about the specifics here but it is interesting to think about how the lifestyle behind the fossil in question and its geographic location affect its size and how we estimate it. Its also good to think about the details of data gathering for these big picture trends, which are not addressed by a lot of the papers we'll read. The Morwood et al paper has some details about specific dating techniques. I don't plan to discuss these at all - just know that they used a variety of techniques to determine the range of dates that bound the geological context of the finds. If you want to understand the specifics of the techniques let me know or try a google search.

Pay special attention to the trends in body size change and the brief mentions of their proposed explanations. Note that even though there is not any life history theory here, we know that major shifts in size must be related to shifts in life history characteristics. What sets body size? Why should an organism get bigger or smaller? But the focus of both papers is the range in variation in body size and the 'clinal' patterning we see in time and space.

Some Flores background:
Most of you have probably heard about the Flores finds - the potentially new species of hominid found on the Island of Flores in the Lesser Sunda Islands a few years ago. Its been hotly debated ever since. A lot of researchers do not like the idea that H. floresiensis is a dwarfed form of H. erectus, but this was the first proposed explanation and still represents an important and current study with implications for human biogeographic patterns of size, colonization, evolution, and so on. It is often referred to as the 'hobbit' because of its very small size.

This is a figure from a news and views piece in Nature by Lahr and Foley that helps place the Flores finds in the context of our evolutionary tree (assuming you accept the finds as that of a new species).


Nature
Published online: 27 October 2004; doi:10.1038/4311043a

Human evolution writ small

Marta Mirazon Lahr & Robert Foley


Fig 1 full size
Figure 1. Homo floresiensis in the context of the evolution and dispersal of the genus Homo.
a, The new species as part of the Asian dispersals of the descendants of H. ergaster and H. erectus, with an outline of the descent of other Homo species provided for context.

b, The evolutionary history of Homo is becoming increasingly complex as new species are discovered. Homo floresiensis (left) is believed1 to be a long-term, isolated descendant of Javanese H. erectus, but it could be a recent divergence. 1, H. ergaster/African erectus; 2, georgicus; 3, Javanese and Chinese erectus; 4, antecessor; 5, cepranensis; 6, heidelbergensis; 7, helmei; 8, neanderthalensis; 9, sapiens; 10, floresiensis. Solid lines show probable evolutionary relationships; dashed lines, possible alternatives.


Here you see how floresiensis compares to other hominin species with respect to brain and body size (from the same article by Lahr and Foley - yes the same Foley that wrote the paper we read in week 2).


Human evolution writ small

Marta Mirazon Lahr & Robert Foley


Fig 2 full size
Figure 2. The relative brain and body size of H. floresiensis.
The dimensions of the skull and skeleton (LB1) described by Brown et al. fall well outside the extremes seen in H. sapiens and the 'erectines' (a range of hominin species, of which H. erectus is the most familiar). LB1 is closer in size to, but even smaller than, the australopithecines, of which the best known example is Lucy. On various anatomical grounds, however, Brown et al. believe that LB1 represents a dwarfed H. erectus.


There is a vast amount of discussion of the Flores finds on the John Hawks blog as well.


Terms and concepts:

clinal variation – [in response to Steven’s question] within a given species or related group of species (also called a taxon), gradual variation in a trait along some geographic axis. For example, the gradual decrease in the size of rabbit ears with increasing latitude is a clinal variation. Another example is a gradual change in some plant’s flower color from red to reddish pink to pink to light pink to white over the plant’s range. If instead the plant just had red flowers in one area and white in another, with no “mixtures” in between, you’d say the plant exhibits “discrete variation” in flower color.

directional selection – [in response to Dennis’s comment] selection toward an extreme version of a trait. For example, a population of rabbits in which small-eared individuals are most likely to survive and reproduce is undergoing directional selection for ear size. Think of direction selection shifting the bell curve for some trait toward one end or the other.

Sexual dimorphism: difference between the sexes. For height this is often expressed as average male size divided by average female size (or vice versa). It is often thought that higher levels of dimorphism reflect important behavioral and mating characteristics. If males compete for access to groups of females, they may have to be very large to fight off rival males. When females and males are closer to the same size it is sometimes considered to indicate a prevalence of monogamy. If so, observing an increasing trend toward lower levels of dimorphism in the hominin fossil record has important implications for social structure and life history. Potentially, when male investment becomes more important, pair-bonds become more stable, and male-male competition over females decreases. This might link to some arguments about slow growing and highly dependent offspring that are key characteristics of the human life history. The grandmother hypothesis that we talked about a few weeks ago is at odds with the view that increased similarity in size between males and females indicates that our species was pair-bonding (stable marriage-like pattern of male-female bonding). The grandmother hypothesis argues that males produce meat from hunting in order to gain access to mates apart from their wives. Essentially, males are actually parasites on the productivity of their wives and their wives' mothers and meat is not really a nutritionally important resource. Please think carefully about interpretations of sexual dimorphism.

stature - height

bi-iliac breadth - this is one of a few measures of human body form mentioned by Ruff. It is the widest distance between the pelvic bones. (the bones that you can feel as your 'hips'). it is measured with a special kind of caliper.

Bergmann's Rule - Mammals and birds tend to be larger at colder temperatures and higher latitudes.

Allen's Rule - Warm-blooded animals tend to have shorter limbs in colder climates.

secular trend - a trend that continues over large periods of time. Often meant to mean directional change.

clinal variation - Gradual continuous change in an observable physical (morphological) trait across space and within the range of some group of related organisms. The observed change is usually related to some environmental feature.

stegodon - an extinct species of elephant. Dwarf stegodons were found near the Flores hominids; in the same levels and close by. A common trend is that large mammals that colonize become much smaller. It has been hypothesized that this process, insular dwarfism, may explain the small hominids on Flores.

what do we call ourselves? There is a lot of nomenclature in the readings this week. Keep in mind that the evolutionary tree for primates is getting reorganized all the time and often this requires using new terms or changing the definition of existing terms. For the most part - hominid refers to all great apes. This includes fossil relatives like australopithicines and living species like chimps, orangutans, and gorillas. Note that for the sake of confusion some authors used hominid to refer to only bipedal ancestors. Hominin is used by Ruff to mean humans and their ancestors (homo sapiens and the extinct varieties of homo that preceded us) but slightly different definitions exist as well.


Condensed abstract of Pilbeam & Gould, 1974, in response to blog query:

Pilbeam, D. and Gould, S.J. 1974. Size and scaling in human evolution. Science 186: 892-901.

“Our general conclusion is simply stated: many lineages display phyletic size increase; allometric changes almost always accompany increase in body size. We cannot judge adaptation until we separate such changes into those required by increasing size and those serving as special adaptations to changing environments.
In our view, the three australopithecines are, in a number of features, scaled variants of the "same" animal. In these characters, A. africanus is no more "advanced" than the larger, more robust forms.
The fossil hominids of Africa fall into two major groupings. One probable lineage, the australopithecines, apparently became extinct without issue; the other evolved to modern humans. Both groups displayed steady increase in body size. We consider quantitatively two key characters of the hominid skull: cranial capacity and cheek tooth size. The variables are allometrically related to body size in both lineages.”

Sunday, September 2, 2007

Readings for Week 3: Humans and biogeography

This week we are reading an article and a couple of sections from a prominent text book in biogeography.

Lomolino, Riddle, and Brown. 2005. Biogeography 3rd Edition, Sinauer Press. pages 3 - 12 and 728 - 743.

Terrell, J. E. 2006. Human biogeography: evidence of our place in nature. Journal of Biogeography 33:2088-2098.



The excerpts from the biogeography text book define the field of biogeography and give good examples of human biogeographic patterns. It also contains good background information on human colonization of the world.

The Terrel paper gives good background for the valuable contributions that biogeography can make to the social sciences. It also provides a philosophical discussion for how perspectives on the human place in nature have changed through time and by discipline. I contacted Dr. Terrell to see if he would be willing to chime in to our blog discussions of his paper. He responded with interest but is traveling next week. As an alternative I will email him a few of our questions and we can post his responses. So please think of very good discussion questions that you can ask to the author directly.


Sunday, August 26, 2007

Readings for week 2

This week we are reading a couple of papers that help us understand what humans are like from an evolutionary perspective while also introducing some important theoretical concepts (Life history theory and the EEA).
Your discussion questions can go as comments to this posting by using the link below. Recall that at least one question should be posted by Monday night at 8:00 pm. You should post two questions during the week. Its up to you if you want to wait until after class on Tuesday to post the second question or post them both at once. Feel free to respond to your classmates questions.

Here is the bibliographic information for this week's papers:

Foley, R.A. 1996. The adaptive legacy of human evolution: A search for the environment of evolutionary adaptedness. Evolutionary Anthropology 4: 194 – 203.

Kim Hill, Hillard Kaplan. 1999. Life History Traits in Humans: Theory and Empirical Studies. Annual Review of Anthropology 28: 397-430

I realize that the Hill and Kaplan paper might be somewhat... thick.... for those of you who have not encountered these concepts before. Please do your best to wade through the material and note sections of the paper where you seem especially confused so we can talk about them in class. Its worth spending time with this paper, however.

Some comments on why these papers were selected:
Its important to understand the basics of Life History Theory (LHT). Only a minority of anthropologists use LHT but its made major contributions to the field in the last couple decades or so. LHT applications to humans are inherently interdisciplinary because they are anthropologists using biological concepts that ultimately derive from economics, which fits the theme of the course quite well. Most life history traits (life span, age at first reproduction, mortality rate, age at independence, etc) tend to scale allometrically with body size when large samples of organisms are considered, like all mammals. Hence, such traits are candidates for law-like generalizations for ecology that are relevant for humans. These scaling relationships describe emergent evolutionary patterns spanning several orders of magnitude in biological organization. LHT is also tied to some important energetic principles that link to other energy-based theories of evolution.

More pragmatically: we want you to be able to define LHT. What is it and what does it tell us? What traits of the human life history seem different from other mammals? How has life history theory been used to explain these difference in humans and what have we learned about human evolution along the way?
Because humans are all over the globe we won't compare just their geographic distribution to other species as an interesting biogeographic pattern. We might focus on the biogeographic distribution of specific traits - life history traits among them.

Foley and the EEA:
The human life history evolved in a nonindustrial environment. This is the link to the environment of evolutionary adaptedness, or EEA. Note that Foley is critical of the EEA concept but along the way in his critique he presents some very relevant information about human ecology and our evolutionary history. We don't want to spend a lot of time going into why some people like the EEA concept and some people don't. A lot of the differences are semantic and have to do with other conflicts between human behavioral ecology and evolutionary psychology that are beyond the scope of this class (not that we can't discuss them some). Clearly, we have lived in different environments in the past but is it the case that past evolutionary environments may have tuned us for contexts very different from where a lot of humans are today? Think critically about how much we can and can't learn about our evolutionary past via the study of extant foraging populations. Do we have enough 'microscopic' studies of human foragers to see the macroscopic patterns relevant to investigating life history variation and the EEA?

We want to know to what degree patterns in modern behavior that seem somehow out of step with the environment are tied to behaviors that were more clearly adaptive at another time and place. Hence, the EEA concept is important in lots of discussions and is often implicit well outside of evolutionary psychology where it was widely adopted.

Also keep in mind the notion of 'human uniqueness' in the context of these papers.

See you Tuesday,
Oskar

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

Readings for week 1

For week one we are reading the first two chapters of two books. The goal is to orient the class on the basic tenets and themes of macroecology and to start thinking about underlying law-like behaviors that often characterize complex ecological and social systems. These chapters are available on ereserves in the folder for week 1. Let one of us know or email humanmacroecology@gmail.com if you have problems with ereserves.

Here's the citation info for the readings:

*Brown, J.H.1995. Chapters 1 – 2 in Macroecology. University of Chicago Press.

*Ginzburg, L., and M. Colyvan. 2004. Chapters 1 – 2 in Ecological Orbits: How Planets Move and Populations Grow. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

The Brown chapters do an excellent job of defining macroecology. Pay attention to the example in chapter 1 for how to 'think big' with regard to an important ecological question. Also think about how Brown approaches the issue of species responses to climate change from a different perspective than would a traditional ecologist. Pay close attention to Brown's discussion of complex systems and ecological complexity in chapter 2.

For the Ginzburg and Colyvan chapter the emphasis is on their discussion of laws and ecology, first and foremost, but also appreciate their use of the analogy between planetary motion and population growth. You may not be familiar with some of the terms and/or concepts in chapter 1. Don't worry. We won't be talking about population dynamics per se. Appreciate that they have their own goals regarding a fascinating topic in population biology (I highly recommend reading the entire book at some point) but their approach to defining the problem and their philosophy of science is what we are most concerned with. Most of this is in chapter 2. You don't really need to read the preface. I only included it because I like the quotes so much. I'll state the one by MacArthur here; "Difficulty in imagining how theory can adequately describe nature is not a proof that theory cannot." Does the Ginzburg and Colyvan approach to thinking about laws and what laws are differ from what you have been taught before?

If you are interested in complex systems approaches to ecology in general check out Brian A. Maurer's book "Untangling Ecological Complexity: The Macroscopic Perspective," published in 1999. This gets more into the specifics of chaos and nonlinearity and might be especially interesting for students with more of a mathematical background. Another good book on the subject is Sole and Goodwin's "Signs of Life: how complexity pervades biology".
 
Locations of visitors to this page